Ranked using 2,767 patient reviews and registry records for 5 local practices.
Quick answer
Our top ranked dental practice in Mattoon, Illinois is Dr. Myles Hastings, DMD, rated 4.9 out of 5 across 498 public reviews. Other top choices include mycharlestondentist.com and Dr. Andrew Caldieraro, DMD. Mattoon has a population of about 16,560, and the 5 strongest local practices are compared on this page.
When it is time to choose a dentist in Mattoon, Illinois, a short, honest list beats scrolling through dozens of ads. We assessed each practice on care quality, experience, and the range of services it offers, not on who pays the most. Use it to shortlist a few offices, then call the one that fits you best.
Across the 5 top practices we highlight in Mattoon, patients can access general dentistry. The Mattoon practices on this list average 12 years in practice, with Dr. Andrew Caldieraro, DMD among the most established at 15 years. Listed offices serve several parts of the city, including the 61938, 61920 ZIP areas. Together these practices hold 2,767 public Google reviews, led by mycharlestondentist.com with 1,491. The average rating across this Mattoon list is 4.8 out of 5.
Are you a dentist in Mattoon?
Claim a featured spot on the Mattoon page with a highlighted card and a direct link to your website.
General Dentistry
Offering general dentistry in Mattoon, serving patients for 8 years. Rated 4.9 out of 5 across 498 public Google reviews.
General Dentistry
Offering general dentistry in Mattoon, an established local practice. Rated 4.8 out of 5 across 1,491 public Google reviews.
General Dentistry
Known in Mattoon for general dentistry, serving patients for 15 years. Rated 4.4 out of 5 across 664 public Google reviews.
General Dentistry
General dentistry in Mattoon, delivered by serving patients for 9 years. Rated 4.8 out of 5 across 92 public Google reviews.
General Dentistry
Offering general dentistry in Mattoon, serving patients for 14 years. Rated 5.0 out of 5 across 22 public Google reviews.
Ratings on this list run from 4.4 to 5.0, review counts from 22 to 1,491, and registry records from 8 to 15 years.
| Rank | Practice | Google rating | Reviews | Years on record | Services |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Dr. Myles Hastings, DMD | 4.9 | 498 | 8 | General Dentistry |
| #2 | mycharlestondentist.com | 4.8 | 1,491 | — | General Dentistry |
| #3 | Dr. Andrew Caldieraro, DMD | 4.4 | 664 | 15 | General Dentistry |
| #4 | Dr. Cody Gass, DMD | 4.8 | 92 | 9 | General Dentistry |
| #5 | Dr. Christopher Painton, DDS | 5.0 | 22 | 14 | General Dentistry |
4 of the 5 Mattoon practices on this page are matched to their record in the US National Provider Identifier registry, and 5 carry a public Google rating. Details were last reviewed on August 28, 2026.
Made the Mattoon top list?
Show it off with our free badge, a simple embed that links back to your Mattoon listing.
The practices we list in Mattoon, Illinois average 4.8 stars. Chicago (5.0), Aurora (4.9), and Rockford (5.0) score a little higher.
A healthy mouth quietly supports the rest of your health. A general dentist in Mattoon, Illinois handles routine care such as cleanings, exams, fillings, and preventive treatment. Consistent care keeps small problems from turning into expensive ones later.
General Dentistry5 of 5 listed practices
General dentists are your first stop for everyday care: checkups, cleanings, fillings, crowns, and preventive advice. In Mattoon, offered by Dr. Myles Hastings, DMD, mycharlestondentist.com, Dr. Andrew Caldieraro, DMD and 2 more.
Treatments available in Mattoon today look very different from a decade ago. Read about recent advances and what to ask your Mattoon dentist.
We rank Mattoon, Illinois practices on review quality and volume, national provider registry records, years in practice, and online presence. Paid placements are always marked as ads.
Read our full ranking methodologyLook at the track record
Among the 5 practices listed in Mattoon, Illinois, registry records show an average of 12 years in operation, and 1 has been on record for 15 years or more. Dr. Andrew Caldieraro, DMD has the longest record at 15 years. Experience matters most for complex work such as implants or root canals.
Read the reviews, not just the stars
The listed Mattoon, Illinois practices hold 2,767 public Google reviews between them, with an average rating of 4.8. A score backed by many reviews, like the 1,491 for mycharlestondentist.com, tells you more than a perfect rating from a handful of patients. Look for recent reviews that mention wait times and how procedures felt.
Pick a practice that covers your needs
Every practice on this Mattoon, Illinois list focuses on general dentistry, so for specialist work such as braces or implants you may be referred to a specialist nearby. Ask about referrals on your first call.
Think about location
The practices here are spread across 2 ZIP codes (61938 and 61920). Being close by matters most if you have kids or need several visits for one treatment.
Start with a checkup
Start small in Mattoon, Illinois: book a checkup, see how the staff treat you, and only then commit to bigger treatment.
A first visit to a Mattoon, Illinois dental office is mostly about getting to know your mouth. The dentist usually takes X rays, checks each tooth, screens your gums, and looks for early signs of trouble. You leave with a written plan, an estimate for any work, and a recommended schedule for the next visit.
Fees across Mattoon, Illinois practices differ by procedure and by coverage. Keeping up with checkups is the cheapest way to avoid bigger bills later. Confirm your plan is accepted when you call a Mattoon office, and get major work quoted first.
Use these questions on your first call to a Mattoon, Illinois dental practice to avoid surprises later.
Dr. Myles Hastings, DMD holds the number 1 spot on our Mattoon list, with a 4.9 star Google rating from 498 reviews. mycharlestondentist.com ranks second with a 4.8 rating.
mycharlestondentist.com has the most public Google reviews among the practices we list in Mattoon, with 1,491. Across all 5 listed practices there are 2,767 reviews in total.
In Mattoon, Illinois, the 5 rated practices we list average 4.8 out of 5 on Google, and the highest rating is 5.0.
Of the practices we list, Dr. Andrew Caldieraro, DMD has the longest record in the national provider registry, at more than 15 years. The average across the list is 12 years.
The Mattoon practices we list are in ZIP codes 61938 and 61920. The biggest cluster is in 61938, with 4 of the 5.
The Mattoon, Illinois ranking comes from one score per practice that blends review quality, review volume, verified credentials, experience, and online presence across the 5 practices we compared.
The organic Mattoon, Illinois ranking cannot be bought. Sponsored placements exist, carry an Ad label, and sit apart from the editorial list.
Are you a dentist?
Claim your spot at the top of your city.