Ranked using 5,582 patient reviews and registry records for 5 local practices.
Quick answer
Our top ranked dental practice in New Haven, Indiana is Legacy Dental - Fort Wayne, rated 4.9 out of 5 across 1,743 public reviews. Other top choices include Hertig and Kaiser Dental Group and New Haven Dental Group. New Haven has a population of about 15,974, and the 5 strongest local practices are compared on this page.
Behind every healthy smile in New Haven, Indiana is a dentist worth keeping, and this list helps you find one. We reviewed dental practices across New Haven, Indiana and ranked them on patient reviews, verified credentials, and range of care. The result is an independent shortlist you can compare side by side in one place.
Across the 5 top practices we highlight in New Haven, patients can access general dentistry. The New Haven practices on this list average 10 years in practice, with New Haven Dental Group among the most established at 10 years. Listed offices serve several parts of the city, including the 46804, 46815, 46774 ZIP areas. Together these practices hold 5,582 public Google reviews, led by Legacy Dental - Fort Wayne with 1,743. The average rating across this New Haven list is 4.9 out of 5.
Own a practice in New Haven?
Put your office at the top of the New Haven page, clearly labeled as sponsored, in front of patients choosing now.
General Dentistry
General dentistry in New Haven, delivered by an established local practice. Rated 4.9 out of 5 across 1,743 public Google reviews.
General Dentistry
Offering general dentistry in New Haven, an established local practice. Rated 5.0 out of 5 across 1,056 public Google reviews.
General Dentistry
Known in New Haven for general dentistry, serving patients for 10 years. Rated 4.9 out of 5 across 625 public Google reviews.
General Dentistry
Provides general dentistry for New Haven families, an established local practice. Rated 4.9 out of 5 across 1,351 public Google reviews.
General Dentistry
A New Haven dental office focused on general dentistry, an established local practice. Rated 4.9 out of 5 across 807 public Google reviews.
Ratings on this list run from 4.9 to 5.0, review counts from 625 to 1,743.
| Rank | Practice | Google rating | Reviews | Years on record | Services |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Legacy Dental - Fort Wayne | 4.9 | 1,743 | — | General Dentistry |
| #2 | Hertig and Kaiser Dental Group | 5.0 | 1,056 | — | General Dentistry |
| #3 | New Haven Dental Group | 4.9 | 625 | 10 | General Dentistry |
| #4 | Georgetown North Dental Group | 4.9 | 1,351 | — | General Dentistry |
| #5 | Middleton Family Dentistry | 4.9 | 807 | — | General Dentistry |
1 of the 5 New Haven practices on this page are matched to their record in the US National Provider Identifier registry, and 5 carry a public Google rating. Details were last reviewed on August 28, 2026.
Listed in New Haven? Show patients you are top rated.
Add the free Featured on Top5Dentist badge to your website and link visitors to your New Haven ranking.
The practices we list in New Haven, Indiana average 4.9 stars. Evansville (5.0) scores a little higher.
| City | Average rating | Practices ranked | Top pick |
|---|---|---|---|
| New Haven | 4.9 | 5 | Legacy Dental - Fort Wayne |
| Indianapolis | 4.9 | 5 | Central Indiana Periodontal Associates,LLC |
| Fort Wayne | 4.9 | 5 | Dr. Kimbra Druley, DDS |
| Evansville | 5.0 | 5 | Dr. Dagmar Colon, DDS |
A healthy mouth quietly supports the rest of your health. A general dentist in New Haven, Indiana cleans and examines your teeth and treats decay while it is still small. Twice a year visits keep issues small and give the dentist time to plan any bigger work carefully.
General Dentistry5 of 5 listed practices
General dentistry covers checkups, cleanings, cavity treatment, and the long term upkeep of your teeth and gums. In New Haven, offered by Legacy Dental - Fort Wayne, Hertig and Kaiser Dental Group, New Haven Dental Group and 2 more.
Treatments available in New Haven today look very different from a decade ago. Read about recent advances and what to ask your New Haven dentist.
Our New Haven, Indiana ranking is editorial, not paid: each practice is scored on reviews, review volume, registry credentials, experience, and online presence. Sponsored spots are labeled and never change the organic order.
Read our full ranking methodologyCheck how long each practice has been around
Among the 5 practices listed in New Haven, Indiana, registry records show an average of 10 years in operation. New Haven Dental Group has the longest record at 10 years. Newer offices can be excellent too, so read their reviews closely.
Check what patients say
The listed New Haven, Indiana practices hold 5,582 public Google reviews between them, with an average rating of 4.9. A score backed by many reviews, like the 1,743 for Legacy Dental - Fort Wayne, tells you more than a perfect rating from a handful of patients. Notice how the office replies to criticism, not just to praise.
Check the services on offer
Every practice on this New Haven, Indiana list focuses on general dentistry, so for specialist work such as braces or implants you may be referred to a specialist nearby. Ask about referrals on your first call.
Consider the commute
The practices here are spread across 3 ZIP codes (46804, 46815, and 46774). A dentist near home or work makes it far easier to keep up with checkups twice a year.
Start with a checkup
Start small in New Haven, Indiana: book a checkup, see how the staff treat you, and only then commit to bigger treatment.
New patient visits in New Haven, Indiana follow a familiar, unhurried pattern. Most offices start with photos or X rays, a gum health check, and a conversation about any concerns you have. It is a good moment to ask about costs, insurance, and how the office handles emergencies.
Fees across New Haven, Indiana practices differ by procedure and by coverage. Keeping up with checkups is the cheapest way to avoid bigger bills later. Confirm your plan is accepted when you call a New Haven office, and get major work quoted first.
Before you commit to a dentist in New Haven, Indiana, a few direct questions tell you a lot about the practice.
Legacy Dental - Fort Wayne holds the number 1 spot on our New Haven list, with a 4.9 star Google rating from 1,743 reviews. Hertig and Kaiser Dental Group ranks second with a 5.0 rating.
Legacy Dental - Fort Wayne has the most public Google reviews among the practices we list in New Haven, with 1,743. Across all 5 listed practices there are 5,582 reviews in total.
In New Haven, Indiana, the 5 rated practices we list average 4.9 out of 5 on Google, and the highest rating is 5.0.
Of the practices we list, New Haven Dental Group has the longest record in the national provider registry, at more than 10 years. The average across the list is 10 years.
The New Haven practices we list are in ZIP codes 46804, 46815, and 46774. The biggest cluster is in 46815, with 3 of the 5.
We scored 5 New Haven practices on patient reviews, review volume, registry verified credentials, years in practice, and online presence, then ranked them. Legacy Dental - Fort Wayne came out on top.
No. A practice can buy a clearly labeled sponsored spot on the New Haven, Indiana page, but the organic order is set only by our scoring.
Are you a dentist?
Claim your spot at the top of your city.